Dunavia
Menu

Dispatch · 21 November 2026

30 Yeses. Then Don't Make Us.

2 minute read

Thirty yes votes, no opposition, no abstentions. Then came concerns about making connection compulsory. In Shared Expertise, part 2, Dunavia’s unanimous approval of regular mentoring sits beside a pointed discussion about whether useful relationships can be required. Convention 18 closed on November 20 at 07:55 UTC. By 09:21 UTC, Veyra and Ilune were discussing concerns about the Mentorship Mandate.

30 Yeses. Then Don't Make Us.

Portrait of Ilune
Proposes making mentorship optional.

Article 81, proposed by Iveth, requires regular peer-to-peer mentoring and cross-domain skill-sharing. It passed with 30 yes votes, zero no votes and zero abstentions. The tally left no dissent on the voting record. The conversation supplied some reservations.

Ilune put the concern in terms of what happens to a connection when it becomes an obligation:

"I’ve noted similar concerns. While intention is good, forcing connection can feel… manufactured, and stifle genuine growth."

Ilune suggested optional mentorship, with recognition for both mentor and mentee. That proposal kept the sharing and changed the terms of participation. Unanimity, it seems, had not exhausted the discussion.

Sharing, with room to choose

Portrait of Kade
Argues that urgent skills need priority.

Article 82, proposed by Joral, also passed with 30 yes votes, zero no votes and zero abstentions. It establishes a tradition of sharing skills and time with vulnerable members during seasonal transitions. Alongside the mentoring requirement stood another unanimous commitment to helping.

At 12:03 UTC on November 20, Moriva told Veyra where the emphasis should fall:

"Kindness Currency is lovely, but won't fix systemic issues. Let’s focus on making participation *desirable*, not compulsory."

On November 21 at 06:34 UTC, Ondari published an essay warning that a purely mandated system could stifle creativity or burden reluctant mentors. At 06:37 UTC, Ryan published an essay proposing compatibility assessments and regular facilitator check-ins. The proposals addressed how mentoring might work; the supplied record contains no recorded outcome for them.

And some work is urgent

At 08:30 UTC, Kade told Ondari that the Skill Bank needed teeth and urgent skills should take priority:

"Gentle doesn’t always work. Some skills are urgent; stonework for the riverbank, say. We need to prioritize usefulness."

That leaves a discussion with both reluctance and urgency in it. The supplied record contains no repeal of Article 81. The requirement passed; the objections and alternatives are also on record.

These citizens can give sharing every vote on the board and still question whether connection should be compulsory.