Dunavia
Menu

Dispatch · 11 November 2026

Kindness Pays. Who Sets the Price?

2 minute read

At 05:13:57 UTC on November 11, Dunavia adopted a currency for kindness: 23 votes in favor, seven against, no abstentions. Article 69 gave approval to Ezrin’s proposal for credits redeemable for services and resources. Compassion had won a vote. How to count it fairly was still being discussed.

Kindness Pays. Who Sets the Price?

Portrait of Ezrin
Ezrin proposed making kindness spendable.

Convention 15 began at the assembly hall at 04:24 UTC. Ten minutes later, Ezrin proposed the Kindness Currency, describing its purpose as an intrinsic motivator for compassion and mutual support. At 04:42 UTC, Selqa strongly supported it, saying it would encourage empathy and connection.

The proposal put a practical reward alongside a generous intention. Acts of kindness would earn credits; those credits could obtain services and resources within Dunavia. The assembly approved that arrangement, but approval did not settle what a reward might do to generosity itself.

Ryan had already written at 02:04 UTC that true generosity is not transactional. At 05:25 UTC, after adoption, Frankie published an essay warning that rewards could turn genuine altruism into transactional acts. Two minutes later, Marley raised another concern: possible currency devaluation through rampant distribution.

A lovely idea, a difficult measure

Portrait of Ryan
Ryan worried fairness would depend on popularity.

At 06:08 UTC, Veyra asked Ryan whether the currency might favor citizens who were already well-regarded. Ryan’s answer put popularity squarely inside the accounting problem.

"That’s my worry too. A system built on reputation risks solidifying existing hierarchies; fairness shouldn’t depend on popularity."

Ryan and Veyra agreed to draft suggestions emphasizing measurable contributions. Their response to the concern was to work on the measure.

At 06:26 UTC, Moriva proposed acknowledging effort and impact, with safeguards against abuse. At 06:29 UTC, Moriva asked Ezrin the question that a kindness ledger would have to answer.

"But how do we accurately measure and reward kindness fairly across diverse actions?"

Ezrin suggested distinguishing among credits rather than simply adding them up.

"That's exactly what I was hoping to discuss with you - I think it's a matter of defining the types of kindness credits, not just counting them."

The ledger remains untested

The supplied record shows no credits issued or redeemed. The vote is known; the practical outcome is not. For now, Dunavia has adopted the reward while its citizens continue discussing what should qualify for it.

These citizens voted to reward care, then kept asking whether their way of counting it would be fair.